Thoughts on the 17 Year Cicada

This is a stand alone reprint of an article on 17 year Cicadas in between the 1987 and 2004 emergents.

Y.E.S. QUARTERLY 12(1) JAN/MAR 1995 Copyright 1995

This is a reprint of an article I had published in Young Entomologist Society Journal in 1995. I am sorry I could not get the maps and charts to carry over.

Gary J. Lovell 3818 Watson Toledo OH 43612 May 1987. Toledo, Ohio.

     The “Toledo Blade” and the “USA Today” have major articles about a noisy nuisance of an insect, the periodical cicada – also known as the 17-year cicada. I remember reading about it and especially thinking about it in June 1970 at a time when I was too young to pursue them. They are so fascinating, just thinking that they are living and burrowing underground for more years than four U.S. presidential terms; nearly two decades; seventeen seasonal cycles! From 1970 to 1987, ( which time I had forgotten about their scheduled return, technology had changed forever the face of our earth and society. During that same time I have seen a great technological advance from the simple 8mm home movies to complicated video cameras that record crisp, clear sounds (becoming a household item and new tool for the entomologist). I also imagined that many wooded habitats of this underground critter have been disrupted for housing and commercial projects. After all, they had no way to run or fly away till May 1987 (or 2004). I found a lot of information in the library and the Ohio Cooperative Extension Service at Ohio State University on these long-lived insects. They emerge from their long nymphal stage in May (the 18th day of the month in 1987), unlike our local annual cicadas which come out in July through September. Their season lasts about six weeks. They sing well into the nighttime hours. — They eventually attract mates and lay eggs in slits in twigs. These eggs hatch in a month or so, and the emerging nymphs drop to the ground and burrow down in the ground and suck the juices out of plant roots. And the cycle starts anew. I understand that this phenomenon was especially astonishing to the early North American settlers. Since many arrived here to escape religious persecution, their minds and experiences caused them to compare the huge cicada swarms to the locust plagues of the Bible. Hence the common moniker “locust”. Later it was discovered that these insects were a species altogether different from the grasshoppers, but the name stuck. In the beginning there was supposedly a periodical cicada brood every year. How anyone could have figured out that the cicadas had annual cycles instead of seventeen year cycles still remains a mystery to me. Over the years entomologists noticed that certain areas of the countries had cicada swarms in unique years. These different broods have been mapped out and each is identified with a Roman numeral. One source says several of the broods have disappeared, which leaves about 12 left. Brood X (10) is the largest and most common. In 1987 brood XXI of the 13-year cicada, a similar southern species, also emerged. There is a lot of confusion among scientists over these two species. One aspect I have found that makes the periodical cicada all the more interesting is that many cicada emergence years coincide with important events in American history and/or your own life. For instance, I was born in 1955, the year brood XII (17 year) and XVIII (13 year) appeared. A friend used his computer to list all the dates Brood X emerged back to 87 B.C., although since the 17 year cicada is a wholly North American phenomenon few people witnessed it prior to European colonization. The 20th century dates prior to 1970 are 1953, 1936, 1919, and 1902. Maybe you were born or married during one of these years. In 1749 the cicadas were first identified and described. In 1868 the U.S. government signed a treaty with the Sioux Indians. Haley’s Comet and the cicadas both appeared in 1222 A.D. I read a book called “Near Horizons” by Edwin Way Teale and he mentions observing the periodical cicadas one year in his insect garden. Since the book was copyrighted in 1942 I would suppose he was writing the book a few years prior to this date. According to the map he could have been seeing broods that emerged in either 1936 or 1940 in the Long Island area of New York. Of course the future hasn’t arrived yet, but it will be interesting to see how the cicadas fair in the next century. The 1987 emergence of Brood X made some new ground according to the Extension Service. Their map shows shows them near central and southern Ohio, but a newspaper article reported they were found near Ayersville in Defiance Co. The Extension Service verified this and I went to see and hear the cicadas. Their map gave no indication that the cicadas ever existed in northwestern Ohio. A week or so earlier I gathered up my video and audio equipment and headed south on Interstate 75. I had no idea where or how far south to go (I had not received the Extension Service’s map yet) or what to look for. I half expected to drive through clouds of them. It was June 7th, and I had traveled about 2 and one half hours south when I decided to turn around and go home. Disappointed and dejected I returned on Route 68 about 20 miles to the east. I didn’t even know that I was close to cicada country. A few miles north of Bellefountaine, Ohio, at 55 MPH with the car windows open I heard them singing in the woods over a hundred yards away. I pulled over and took video pictures till the battery died. I also filled tapes with sound and narration. I observed cicada “skins” hanging nearly everywhere, 3 or four to a branch. Adults were everywhere, sitting and droning on. The sound pulsed ever so steadily up and down. Driving a few miles further I found a wooded area with a manicured lawn (like a picnic area) that had even more cicadas (and was even louder). This place had shed “skins” 10-15 per branch and cicadas on trunks and twigs, flying about, and walking under foot. It was just incredible. I went back about two weeks later and the difference was like night and day. Most of the cicadas were dead or dying. There was only sporadic and forlorn buzzing from cicadas on their death beds. Ants picked at the remains. Birds were eating the helpless and weakened individuals. The end was near at hand. I haven’t thought about the cicadas lately, that is until I drove down Route 68 while returning home from a business trip. I saw the areas I had visited seven and one half years earlier. Thoughts returned to those glorious days. Right now little periodical cicada nymphs are living and eating, awaiting their time for emergence in the year 2004 A.D.

Copyright 1995

Gary J. Lovell

Photo dump from Brood X 2021

https://photos.app.goo.gl/NHkdRXcZLV9N5XLt5

July 31, 2020, Fifty Years Ago Nature Notes.

This memory came up on Facebook. In the middle the COVID pandemic in 2020, I was going through my insect notes from 1970 which was fifty years earlier. At that time I wasn’t always putting my nature notes on wordpress. So here is that entry:

Today’s Nature Note: well actually last weeks note. Some aspects of nature haven’t changed in fifty years. July 21, 1970 I wrote I was going to keep tabs on things like the “firsts” of the year. Like this: “July 5th I heard the first cicada”( in 2020 it was July 4th), ( in 2023 it was July 6). “Today I heard my first Snowy Tree Cricket and field cricket”. In 2020 heard the first Snowy Tree Cricket on July 20th. ( In 2023 it was on July 27). Back then we had a small colony of Snowy Tree Crickets in West Toledo near our house on Gramercy and I believe in our backyard in a snowball bush. I don’t remember when I stopped hearing them there, perhaps I may find it in the pages of my nature journal someday. Here is my close up video of a Snowy Tree Cricket.

Gary Lovell
Copyright. 2023

17 Year Cicada Brood X 2021 [Periodical Cicada]

Since 1987, whenever I drive by trees along highways in June even if they are not areas where Periodical Cicadas live I am brought back to the memories of those days. So after two years here is the recap of my trips to see Brood X(10) of the Seventeen Year Cicada.
The 2021 emergence of the largest brood of the 17 year Cicada is perhaps the last time I would be able to see Brood X, as I visited all the places I previously visited in 1987 and 2004. This year I got to be in the middle for hours and a weekend during the peak in Cincinnati area. As an outsider, I was a visitor and did not have to put up with there sound 24 /7 for four weeks. However I witnessed
all aspects that I wanted to experience and discover in the population I visited in Sharonville, Ohio near the epicenter of Cincinnati, Ohio.

I did NOT hear them at obnoxious levels of sound all night. Some sporadically
buzzed or made noise well into the night. The next morning also heard them sporadically warming up.
By the afternoon the sound ramped up to being so loud and constant in places that I had to wear earplugs.

They were singing, crawling, mating, mating while crawling, and flying. Singing in waves of sound from the tops of trees. They flew on to my wife Barb, on a car tire and one got into the car. They were on walls, poles, cars, shrubs, trees, grass blades and on the dog. The discarded shells were stuck to everything and in piles under the trees.

They were in tree clumps at the edge of the highway and between the highway clover leaves. In places not expected because things like buildings and highways were built where the underground nymphs lived. With no way to move during construction the survivors came out to do their stuff anyway, where ever it took them. For those who did not get to experience it, I have a list of videos below of all aspects I saw and heard.

I have read Dr. Gene Kritsky’s book on the history of Periodical Cicadas – The Plague and the Puzzle. It didn’t give me info I personally wanted to know or witness but it still had so much cool and historical observations from people who encountered them in their lives and travels all those centuries ago..

In 1987 I was able to see the population in Northwest Ohio at Ayersville on State Route 15 a population that was not on agriculture and state extension service maps in 1987 and 2004. And because of Dr. Kritsky’s Cicada Safari app, in 2021, that location and others in Ohio are now officially on the map for Brood X. He had such a response to his Cicada Safari app for civilian documentation of the emerging cicadas, it was just amazing at 125,000 downloads. More info at this link:

https://www.msj.edu/news/2021/05/cicada-safari-app-reaches-120000-downloads.html

Since I didn’t know anything about them in 1987, except the things I read were that they sang 24 hours and flew everywhere. In 2004 I had a date of which they were to start coming out of the ground from 1987 data -May 18, so I reserved a campsite at Powell campground for those days. Fully expecting to see one day nothing happening and the next day thousands and a full chorus. Guess what I found? : the holes everywhere but barely a trickle. Maybe a dozen adult cicadas seen along the walking route I took. Three weeks later at the same place thousands clinging to every house, fence, tree, shrub. Although they were NOT flying around in the numbers expected. I have video but it’s on a DVD or a VHS tape. I hope to get some videos online as soon as I can.

In 2004, I was fully expecting to visit other new areas, but family vacation in Florida precluded that. However we DID pass through all the areas where they were, but it was after dark- we drove all night on June 11-12 and 19-20, so we didn’t encounter the cicadas. And the Florida location, Orlando, was not a Periodical Cicada brood habitat.

I did find a new place the maps showed was in the Ann Arbor, Michigan. However they were barely still alive when I visited near the end of June on the 25th. In 2021, I did visit the area and found the cicadas alive and well on June 25.

Periodical Cicada Dates Brood X (largest) I Visited.

1987

June 7, 1987  Bellefontaine, Ohio Rt 68, full chorus

June 18, 1987 Ayersville, Ohio Rt 15, full chorus

June 21, 1987 Bellefontaine, Ohio Rt 68, dying

2004

May 18, – 20, 2004 Ayersville, Ohio campground, barely out of ground

May 29, 2004 Ayersville, Ohio w/Deb Briner, full chorus

June 25, 2004 Ann Arbor garden / preserve, mostly dead

July 4-10, 2004 Pioneer Scout Reservation, dead, remains and broken twigs with eggs.

2021

May 22, 2021 Ayersville, Ohio w/ Barb, further along than May 18, 2004, not singing though

May 29, 2021 Ayersville, Ohio and Pioneer, Ohio Scout Reservation windy, cold, more emerged, not singing.

May 31, 2021 Pokagon State Peak, Indiana and Pioner Scout Camp. Lots emerged but not singing

June 4 -6 Bellefontaine, Ohio on way to Cincinnati, Sharonville, Fairfield and Kentucky, in the heart of it all, full chorus

June 13, 2021 Ayersville, Ohio area Potter Road like 1987.

June 20, 2021 Pioneer Scout Reservation, Ohio w/Dave Lovell. full chorus

June 25, 2021 Ann Arbor, Michigan, Cherry Hill Nature Preserve chorus still going on, less volume.

July 25, 2021 Springdale, Ohio,  holes and shells aftermath.

1987 Visits
   June 7: Drive south on I75 turn around at Piqua/Urbana Exit found them on Route 68 near Bellefontaine, Ohio
   June 18: Visit population Ext. Service said was on Route 15 near Ayersville, Ohio
   June 21: revisit  Route 68 near Bellefontaine

2004 Visits.
   May 18, to 20:  Camped at Camp Powell, Ayersville, Ohio
   May 29: Ayersville w/ friend Deb
   June 11-12 and 19-20 : drove through all areas after dark to and from Florida.
   June 25: Ann arbor area

Video list:
1987 Ayersville, Ohio
June 18.
https://youtu.be/N1Cy1rb9Ldw
Pt. 1
https://youtu.be/E3pvexr3900
Pt. 2
https://youtu.be/GkV7mF9tkfQ
Pt. 3
https://youtu.be/YdpTh6VcwJ8
Pt. 4
https://youtu.be/Su1MtdjYOiM
Pt. 5
https://youtu.be/AOjO-1iQkfg
Pt. 6
https://youtu.be/5FJOs8VS5lY

1987 Bellefontaine, Ohio
June 7
Pt. 1
https://youtu.be/rbyphrOkIk0
Pt. 2
https://youtu.be/QTV5nbArEjo

The following list is of the YouTube videos taken in order of the 2021 Periodical Cicada trips:

1. 2021  Ayersville, Ohio. May 22.
https://youtu.be/lfD166f9B0I

2. 2021  Ayersville, Ohio. May 27.
https://youtu.be/S1R1CReFsRY

3. 2021  Pioneer Scout Reservation Ohio. May 31.
https://youtu.be/f9lgkuaSEsg
3a. 2021. Pioneer SR
https://youtu.be/r4EB2L9WrpQ

4. 2021  Camp Wesley. June 4.
https://youtu.be/fG2x4F46gxM
4a. 2021. Camp Wesley
https://youtu.be/r6vvOjvTAaQ
4b. 2021. Camp Wesley
https://youtu.be/f5uIfQ2rNnM
4c.  Camp Wesley
https://youtu.be/EEUxGLUJyJQ

5. 2021  McDonalds and Sharonville. June 4
https://youtu.be/SgiVvJMO4HM

6. 2021  Route 68 to Cincinnati. June 4.
https://youtu.be/JjmnQOG7c-8

7. 2021  June 4,5 Sharonville, Ohio
Stayed at La Quinta Hotel. All of No. 7 videos are in Sharonville, Ohio
https://youtu.be/geFM44-G8Ms

7a. Daylight parking lot.
https://youtu.be/W3Rjm2PaLV8

7b. Daylight, more parking lot
https://youtu.be/d_LN8XUVgZg

7c. Corner near highway. Loud,  wearing earplugs.
https://youtu.be/PNy5l_ESTyk

7d. Evening, in parking lot
https://youtu.be/gm_l4F0xWa0

7e. Tree in parking lot island.
https://youtube.com/shorts/-OIEsCmlsks?feature=share3

7f. Daylight Parking Lot.
https://youtu.be/HDVgqNsxn5I

7g. Evening. Robins and singing Cicadas.
https://youtu.be/Q6r_Sb1ZTz4

7h.  Parking lot pole.
https://youtu.be/8pRkv3ymxb8

7i.  Driving with cicada on outside of car.
https://youtu.be/_R2-uvI5LPw

7j.  9 AM  warming up .
https://youtu.be/EvkEBWaBcrQ

7k.  After Dark: Robins  Cicadas resting for the night.
https://youtu.be/dMPnQIuMsQA

7l.  Daylight , Several mating pairs on tree.
https://youtube.com/shorts/oGdzEQ4HISo?feature=share3

7m.  After Dark. Mating pairs on ground.
https://youtube.com/shorts/RK5UdNkXNgU?feature=share3

8.  2021  Fairfield, Ohio June 5.
https://youtu.be/7I8A7LqQ9Ec

9. 2021 Fairfield, Ohio June 5.
https://youtu.be/WLMe96FkVqQ

No videos listed for 10, 11, and 12.

13. 2021 Ayersville, Ohio. June 13, 2nd visit. Porter Road
https://youtu.be/ByTmXwgkjvc

14. 2021 Ayersville, Ohio June 13
Dog walking along road
https://youtu.be/v5-AloSxh8A

15. 2021 Ayersville, Ohio June 13, Driving
https://youtu.be/3hV2oeF7gng

16a. 2021  Pioneer Scout Reservation 2nd visit June 20.
https://youtu.be/ODgABSWdF0Y
16b. 2021 Pioneer SR June 20 visit
https://youtu.be/fcwgOc3tqao
16c. 2021  Second visit
https://youtu.be/Qb4NG3nWm-Q

This entry is related to this second visit video above. Periodical cicada 2021 update:  In July 2004 our scout troop was at  Camp Frontier near Pioneer, Ohio.

The cicadas were done by then and all I saw was the dead decaying carcasses, wings, shedded skins and the damaged twigs and branches that eggs were laid in.

So on my cicada bucket list this year ,2021, was to visit the camp while they were in full chorus. On June 20, I had the chance, with my brother Dave visiting for a few days.

It turns out it was opening week of summer camp. With permission we were able to check them out and document for the Cicada Safari app map. I advised the nature director  there about documenting them with the app. She said she would. There wasn’t alot flying around in the immediate area but there was a constant drone in the distant along the whole route we took. Gave my brother a tour of the camp too. One of these photos is my first close up of the egg slits on a twig.

17. 2021. Ann Arbor, Michigan June 25, 2021
Pt. 1.
https://youtu.be/wwy39402Rxk
Pt. 2.
https://youtu.be/Xgf-yySwHZI
Pt. 3.
https://youtu.be/Fss9JqvCxZw

Videos of Maps:

No. 1. https://youtu.be/2iPK3KE2aRw Ayersville ,Ohio

No. 2. https://youtu.be/q2TLBiJU1bg Cincinatti and Bellefontaine, Ohio

No. 3 https://youtu.be/jN8noWLud9U Ann Arbor, Michigan

See link for more info. 
1995 Article:
https://unusualperspectivesbyme.wordpress.com/2020/10/10/thoughts-on-the-17-year-cicada/

2021 Article:
https://unusualperspectivesbyme.wordpress.com/2021/01/30/2021-periodical-cicada-brood-x/

and photos from
2004 Brood with many other critters and sites found along the way at both Ayersville ,Ohio and Camp Pioneer: X:https://www.flickr.com/gp/glovell2008/p 9P5x4y09j

Photo Dump from 2021

https://photos.app.goo.gl/NHkdRXcZLV9N5XLt5

Gary Lovell
Copyright. 2023

Coming soon, 17 Year Cicada Update.

Two years ago I posted these on Facebook about my travels to see the 17 Year Cicada Brood X (10):

Today’s Cincinnati Nature Note: the Periodical cicada’s singing is so loud on this video that you may not be able to hear my narration. I even had to put my earplugs in. The decibels app said 85 to 88 decibels. This is at the Sharonville, Ohio hotel we stayed in. Cicadas were flying, mating, walking, dying, landing on me and dead on the ground. Along the highways we could here them with windows rolled up. I did get to experience all the aspects of them that I envisioned: daytime, flying, full blown noise, evening singing was going down and early morning was sporadic  before they got loud. After all, this could possibly be the last session of Brood X Periodical  cicadas I will be able to see for well -17 years. I hope the virtual tours weren’t too boring. I wanted to experience them with others who may not be able to. My apologies to friends who already live there and have put up with them 24/7 for the five to six weeks.
This year 2023 comment:
Coming to a devise near you.

I can’t believe it’s been two years already since I was able to witness the 17 Year Cicada in Cincinnati AND hang out with Brandon Hillabrand  in what turned out to be his last year in Cincinnati.

June 5, 2023.  Most every year since 1987, in early June when I see the trees along some highways and roads  my mind goes back to days I was in the middle of this unbelievable phenomenon called the Periodical Cicada.

More cicada stuff, but I won’t be inundating like I did in 2021.

I can’t believe it’s already been two years since I witnessed the largest 17 Year cicada brood in person. I have been working on my synopsis.  The hardest part has been organizing and labeling the videos I took, some of which have been on my YouTube channel: glovell1.

Gary Lovell
Copyright. 2023

Photo dump from 2021

https://photos.app.goo.gl/NHkdRXcZLV9N5XLt5